A List of Ulduar Tuning Errors

This is a really helpful list, Garyoak. Thank you!

To set expectations; the strict definition of what exactly is pre-nerf is a bit less clear than in previous tiers, because many of these fights had numerous changes over time so we might choose not to set one data value or another to one specific point in time universally, instead opting for a later or earlier state that make sense stacked alongside other iterations of that boss that we are reverting to. One thing we mentioned in our recent WoW Community Council discussion was that we need to be careful about reverting these fights to pre-nerf as there may be a combination of changes that were made at different times that, if all reverted together thoughtlessly, would create a version of the fight that was never experienced by players at all. To a degree this is somewhat unavoidable, especially on fights that had bugs or other very early adjustments, but we are trying to minimize this as much as possible.

All that being said, just eyeballing this list there’s very likely some things in here we might have missed or would want to revisit based on the values we chose initially, and we’ll be looking at it.

Thank you again for compiling this!